Gold vs S&P 500: Q1 2026 Scorecard

Gold just delivered one of its best quarters in decades. The S&P 500 had a decent quarter too — but it wasn't even close. Here's the full Q1 2026 scorecard.

Q1 2026: The Numbers

Metric	Gold	S&P 500
Q1 2026 return	+18.2%	+4.1%
YTD (to Apr 12)	+22%	+5.5%
1-year return	+52%	+14%
Worst single day (Q1)	-2.1%	-3.4%
Best single day (Q1)	+3.8%	+2.1%
Q1 volatility (annualized)	~18%	~16%
Starting price (Jan 1)	$3,850/oz	5,880
Ending price (Mar 31)	$4,550/oz	6,121

Gold outperformed the S&P 500 by 4.4x in Q1. This is the fourth consecutive quarter where gold has beaten stocks.

Check the live gold price for where we stand now.

Why Gold Is Winning

Three forces are driving gold's outperformance over stocks in 2026:

1. Central Bank Buying Hasn't Slowed

Central banks bought over 300 tonnes of gold in Q1 2026 alone — on pace for another 1,000+ tonne year. This structural demand floor doesn't exist for stocks. China, India, Poland, and Turkey continue to diversify reserves away from the dollar. Read our deep dive: how central banks are buying record gold.

2. Inflation Is Stickier Than Expected

January CPI came in at 3.2%, February at 3.0%, March at 2.9%. The Fed's 2% target remains elusive. Shelter and services inflation are proving stubborn. Gold thrives in this environment — investors buy it precisely because they don't trust the Fed to contain prices. See is gold a hedge against inflation?

Stocks, meanwhile, are hurt by sticky inflation because it delays rate cuts that the market has been pricing in for over a year.

3. Geopolitical Risk Premium

Escalating trade tensions, Middle East instability, and ongoing sanctions regimes keep safe-haven demand elevated. Gold benefits directly from geopolitical uncertainty; stocks suffer from it. Read what drives the gold price for the full framework.

Should You Be Worried About Stocks?

No — a single quarter of underperformance isn't a reason to abandon equities. Context matters:

Period	Gold	S&P 500	Winner
Q1 2026	+18.2%	+4.1%	Gold
2025 full year	+47%	+12%	Gold
2024 full year	+27%	+23%	Gold (barely)
Last 5 years	+155%	+85%	Gold
Last 10 years	+180%	+170%	Gold (barely)
Last 30 years	~7.5%/yr	~10.2%/yr	Stocks

Gold is clearly winning the current cycle. But over 30+ year periods, stocks have historically outperformed gold thanks to earnings growth and dividend reinvestment. For a deeper analysis, see our full gold vs stocks comparison.

The lesson isn't to pick one or the other — it's to hold both. A 10-15% gold allocation alongside stocks reduces drawdowns without significantly hurting long-term returns.

The Portfolio Effect

Here's how a blended portfolio performed in Q1 vs pure stock or pure gold:

Portfolio	Q1 2026 Return	Max Drawdown (Q1)	Sharpe Ratio
100% S&P 500	+4.1%	-5.8%	0.52
90% S&P + 10% Gold	+5.5%	-4.6%	0.61
80% S&P + 20% Gold	+6.9%	-3.5%	0.72
60% S&P + 40% Gold	+9.7%	-2.1%	0.88
100% Gold	+18.2%	-2.1%	1.12

Every portfolio with gold allocation outperformed pure stocks on both return AND risk-adjusted basis in Q1. The 80/20 blend hit a sweet spot: nearly +7% return with only -3.5% max drawdown vs stocks' -5.8%.

This isn't always the case — in periods of low inflation and strong economic growth, gold drags on portfolio returns. But in the current macro environment, gold allocation is paying off handsomely.

What Q1 Results Mean for Gold Allocation

If gold's Q1 outperformance has pushed your allocation above target, you have two options:

1. Rebalance — Trim gold back to your target (say 10-15%). This locks in gains and buys stocks at relatively lower prices. Disciplined but feels painful when gold is running.

2. Let it ride — Don't rebalance until year-end. If the drivers (central banks, inflation, geopolitics) are still in place, gold may keep outperforming. Less disciplined but potentially more rewarding.

For most investors, annual rebalancing is the right approach. See how much gold should you own for allocation guidelines, or dollar-cost average in if you're building a new position.

Q2 Outlook

Heading into Q2 2026, the setup still favors gold:

• Fed meeting in May — Markets expect a hold. If they hint at rate cuts, gold rallies. If they stay hawkish, stocks suffer more than gold.
• Central bank buying continues — No sign of slowdown in Q2 based on reported purchases
• Election uncertainty — US political cycle adds volatility that typically benefits gold
• Tariff/trade escalation risk — Any new trade barriers would boost gold and hurt stocks

For specific price targets, see our gold price forecast for 2026-2030. Analysts see $5,000-$6,300 by year-end — implying another 8-35% upside from current levels.

The Bottom Line

Q1 2026 was gold's quarter. Whether Q2 and beyond will be the same depends on inflation, central bank policy, and geopolitics. But the structural case for holding gold alongside stocks has never been stronger.

If you don't own any gold, Q1 results make a strong argument for adding a 10% allocation. Use our gold vs inflation calculator to see how gold has performed against inflation over any period, or check the best gold ETFs to find the cheapest way to get started.

---

This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Always consult a qualified financial advisor before making investment decisions.